Jump to content

Navionics--what is the 'real' accuracy?


SirCranksalot

Recommended Posts

I know the charts show contour lines with 2-3 ft interval, but I was fishing yesterday and my sonar showed me an area 10ft deeper than an area further out even though the chart does not show any depression in that area. I know they can't show every tiny little up and down checked a couple of points about 100 ft apart and they were both about 10 ft deeper than further out..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've found it to be up to 5 feet off, and other times I've found it exact to the foot. I was looking for a small depression on simcoe a week ago, dropping from 20 to 32 foot of water and back. I walked straight on top of it, shot through with the sonar, and found the exact depth, and my buddy and I laughed and thought it was pretty good. Other times it's been a bit off. They are only as good as the cartographic data they have obtained. I find them to be accurate or close enough more often than not!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the maps that have been redone recently are very accurate

 

others are not even close because of the way the determined the depth , as the got the depth every so far, then just grew lines between them

 

gps is never right on either and clouds and location can also lessen accuracy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There are certain lakes where the maps are slightly "off". The GPS might say you're 100m away from shore but in reality it may be half of that. Not a big problem, just use the numbers as a reference to the contours in a lake

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've noticed it depends on the lake, some are more accurate then others. I've seen different versions give different info some reason too. I'm not sure why they can't group all the data. As an example, there's a few humps on a specific lake that show up on my gold chart that don't show up on navionics+ chart which is supposed to be conclusive. In terms of accuracy though, every lake differs from what I've noticed... some are close, sometimes it's way off. I take it with a grain of salt. It's good for getting an idea of an area, then use your fishfinder.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

People also need to realize that their GPS isn't as accurate as they think.. Civilian vs military is a HUGE difference, lol. I think they say something like 7 metres @ 95% of the time?

 

That being said, I haven't had to mess with the offset on my HB 898 too much. It's usually pretty spot on.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There is a lot of variance in chart water depths, largely because water levels vary from year to year, and throughout the course of a season. A spot that's 12 feet deep in the spring might have only 9 feet of water over it in the fall. Hence the phrase "at chart datum" ... which means that the depth was accurate when the soundings for that particular chart were taken.

 

Many Canadian charts are using base maps from the 1970s. They're obviously nowhere near as accurate as more recent ones.

 

Between that and the +/- variance of GPS on a given day, use it as a rough guide but don't expect it to be right on the button all of the time. It still beats holding your thumb up and trying to line up with trees on the shore.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't see the water level as an issue

I can tell pretty quick if levels are up or down and expect the depth to be different but I would still expect the depth between the top of the hump and the bottom to always be the same distance

and water levels don't cause a hump to not be where the map is, or drop offs to move

it is maps aren't accurate and gps is off

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Lol. Where I fish on rainy river the chart stops EXACTLY where I like to fish.

 

Oh well Ive figured it out but a proper chart coulda saved me some time lol.

 

It is what it is.

 

This is a good reminder to be careful using navionics on lakes filled with reefs, just in case.

Edited by manitoubass2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Most chart and nav data is always taken at low water datum !!!!! Just like govt charts are supposed to be as to always err on the side of caution for navigation as well as Wayne said above in his post some maps are on old surveys and not on the newer GPS coordinates it's a lot better than it was 15yrs ago when. The US military under orders from the president made GPS a lot more accurate for civilian use it's quite the story about it too It' was sketchy at best back then and if it was on that day it was pretty good and some days it was brutal !!!! They were scrambling the signal up to 35% it something like that ..... So it's def way way better today ....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let me explain myself a bit better than my orig post:

 

I was not using a GPS with Navionics on it. I just printed out a small section of the lake where we would be fishing. Nevertheless, I had quite an accurate idea of where I was from looking around me in the small cove we were in.If I believe my sonar readings, there should be a 'dip' or depression in the area that I checked----indicated by concentric closed loops. But there is no such indication on the map. The map shows the depth increasing more or less uniformly with further dist from the shore.

 

So, while GPS accuracy is a pertinent topic for this forum, it's not really relevant to the issue on this thread.(I guess I should have elaborated a bit more in the first place :unsure: ).

 

I don't see the seasonal variation of water level to be particularly important. I.e. I'm interested in the relative depth-----the 'holes', bumps, ridges---the 'structure'--- rather than the absolute depth.

 

I have to wonder where Navionics gets their very detailed 'data'. Has somebody really surveyed the lakes in such detail?? Or, did they take the cruder contours shown on gov't charts and interpolate them like crazy??

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recent Topics

    Popular Topics

    Upcoming Events

    No upcoming events found

×
×
  • Create New...