Thanks for the input so far guys!
I'm partial to the "feel" of the Fenwicks. I've had three or four Highlanders, which are the CTire cheap-Fenwicks and other than me dropping/scraping/catching in doors, these units have done me very well. I just love the light sensitive "feel" they offer. In comparison, I find almost every equally priced ($50-80) rod feels like a tree-trunk.
I've heard about the Fenwick quality dropping over time, but the other side of the coin is just as evident. It would a tough choice for me to leave this brand.
Unfortunately I don't have the convenience of shopping large fishing stores...it's tough to do brand comparisons in North Bay.
The HMG seems like a decent upgrade over the Highlander...especially if I can catch this sale...$75 looks like a great price. The Compre is closer to $100.
The BPS ratings are good btw.