John,
When it comes down to it, it's up to the individual whether he's going to keep the fish or not, as long as it's within the regs.
I wouldn't keep a fish like that myself, but I can't impose my personal views on somebody else. I could try to persuade somebody I'm fishing with, but it's ultimately up to him/her.
(Just like it's up to the boat owner whether to go with a tiller or console, even though the right answer is TILLER).
Mike
Whopper: I just looked at the thread again, he was definitely respected and nobody brought up the keep issue...