no, not at all...no way i would back 100% no kill,but like moosbunk said for areas of concern,reduced limits or all c&a but i think the key is to make sure its a sustainable resource,or in lakes that are stocked like the put & take fisheries go for it take fish home,but we as anglers must do whats right,and make sure we protect what we have and we should all practice sustainable harvest,or at the very least make sure the spawners go back and keep a few for the table....and the number one thing is to practice safe handling of all fish that are to be released as to cut down on the mortality.....it would go along ways to help the fisheries...educate the masses about the states of certain fisheries and the impact that negative practices can have on them.....