Jump to content

Scary stuff on Walleye populations


Acountdeleted

Recommended Posts

Very interesting...

 

Makes sense tho... Think about how many acres of "dead" or unproductive water there are where you target walleye...

 

Therefore there are areas with high populations with vast areas with little to no fish...

 

So on a 10 acre mud flat with a rock pile may have 50 walleye on the rocks and only a handful in the other 9.5 acres...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I can see what you are saying.

 

What concerned me the most was let's say me and my 4 closest buddies pile into a boat and go to our favourite 500 acre lake. We each keep our limit on walleye. That's 1% of the entire population. Let's say 4 other boats do that. That's 5% of the population in one day. Over a summer and winter of constant fishing pressure, that lake doesn't stand a chance.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Very interesting...

 

Makes sense tho... Think about how many acres of "dead" or unproductive water there are where you target walleye...

 

Therefore there are areas with high populations with vast areas with little to no fish...

 

So on a 10 acre mud flat with a rock pile may have 50 walleye on the rocks and only a handful in the other 9.5 acres...

Yes, but that's no different then any lake in North America, however many lakes give you a much better success rate all while being even more challenging to the angler.

 

Take the best walleye lake in North America........Lake Erie...it's HUGE vast areas of unproductive waters that some will fish for days or even seasons without much success, others will limit out with huge walleyes that make pictures pop out on any site.

 

What we have today is not much different that what was available 50 years ago.....fish and be happy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I always think about the old saying "90% of the fish hold in 10% of the water" before I go to a spot, I think I saw this last week and it sure made me think about the sustainability of some lakes as well as why some people find walleye fishing so tough lol :P

Link to comment
Share on other sites

good info. I am in between l.erie and lsc. this region holds more walleyes then many lakes combined. with spawn cycles the foremost important factor,and mother nature give when eggs are laid. . one day we will see erie and walleyes crash. the phosphates of the 60,s are gone,but now theres several lurkers ready to create the perfect storm. sadly most are man made.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

years ago the mnr did a creel survey on the lake I live on and came to the conclusion that it was being fished 600% more than it could sustain. there are maybe 10 private residences on it, with 5 of them being fulltime residences. there are also 5 tourist resorts on the lake.

 

add to this the fact the lake is accessible by locals by travelling down stream from Red Lake into it.

 

the fishing was going down hill but the camp owners, to their credit, came up with the rule for all to follow (voluntarily). that no fish over the legal size limit would be allowed in their camps and no fish over the size limit that was allowed in the regulations would be allowed,

 

the local private residents for the most part, follow this as do the summer residents that have cabins on the lake.

 

today the lake is teaming with walleye and it is not unusual for a boat of 4 from a tourist camp to catch over 50 walleye a day and still take home their limit ( most take the conservation licence).

 

while I'm on the lake I see more and more people taking pictures of the fish and releasing them. it all helps the lake survive and provide for future generations

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the fishing was going down hill but the camp owners, to their credit, came up with the rule for all to follow (voluntarily). that no fish over the legal size limit would be allowed in their camps and no fish over the size limit that was allowed in the regulations would be allowed,

 

 

I hope you aren't saying that once everyone started to play by the rules and care about others playing by the same provincial/ zone wide regulations that the fishery became sustainable again. Maybe I am reading this wrong lol (and if I am I am terribly sorry!), but the legal size limit isn't something that can voluntarily be obeyed. It is the law, why would these camps tolerate people keeping more than their limits and larger fish than their limits in that zone permitted them to take?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

good info. I am in between l.erie and lsc. this region holds more walleyes then many lakes combined. with spawn cycles the foremost important factor,and mother nature give when eggs are laid. . one day we will see erie and walleyes crash. the phosphates of the 60,s are gone,but now theres several lurkers ready to create the perfect storm. sadly most are man made.

 

 

You do have to wonder if the Phosphates are really gone? Or has the source of them simply changed? The water problems in Toledo Ohio this year seem to indicate the same old problem? Just a different source of it? Agricultural runoff is putting them back into the system, just as detergents did in the past? More agriculture to support a growing population and more runoff? It doesn't seem like the land gets a rest to replenish itself naturally, population growth doesn't allow for that, so the use of chemical fertilizers grows?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recent Topics

    Popular Topics

    Upcoming Events

    No upcoming events found

×
×
  • Create New...