Jump to content

Erie vs. Kawartha Walleye  

30 members have voted

  1. 1. which ones taste better

    • Erie
      8
    • Kawartha
      10
    • They taste the same
      12


Recommended Posts

Posted

Personally I like them both but perfer the smaller ones that are readily available in the Kawarthas. I have a hard time catching them small enough for my liking in Erie.

Posted

Just finished a plate of Erie eyes from last week , all about 3 pounds. No difference, both are awesome!

Whichever is closer...but erie can take the pressure better

Posted

well i think that the kawartha walleyes taste better than erie,or lake ontario walleyes because ,the great lakes walleyes eat alot of alewifes,and shad,which are very oily :glare: ,as the kawarthas walleyes dont have that in their diet,and are not oily at all,and so these walleyes eat alot of perch :clapping: so they are for sure better tasting than the great lakes walleyes....cheers :thumbsup_anim::Gonefishing:

Posted
well i think that the kawartha walleyes taste better than erie,or lake ontario walleyes because ,the great lakes walleyes eat alot of alewifes,and shad,which are very oily :glare: ,as the kawarthas walleyes dont have that in their diet,and are not oily at all,and so these walleyes eat alot of perch :clapping: so they are for sure better tasting than the great lakes walleyes....cheers :thumbsup_anim::Gonefishing:

 

 

BINGO!!

 

I like my pickeral between 12-16".....anyhting bigger is just not the same.

 

SInker

Posted
Real hard to beat a Mcdonalds filet!

 

Are you referring to the Mystery fish? LOL

 

They used to call Mc's Fillet-O- Fish North Atlantic Whitefish....or in simpler terms, Cod.

 

With the Cod stocks down who the hell knows what they are using now :dunno:

 

As for which walleye tastes better, I'd say the ones that are known as Pickerel :whistling::D

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recent Topics

    Popular Topics

    Upcoming Events

    No upcoming events found

×
×
  • Create New...