Really? I can't understand how you guys have trouble getting the rods out of a Salty. You just lift the rod straight up. I've used Salties, Berts, Cannons, Scotty Quick Draws, & Scotty Orcas and I find that Salties to be the easiest to get the rod out of. The only other holder that even comes close to the Salty for ease in removing the rod is the Scotty Orca.