I'll let OFC decide

[NAW]

Some of you might remember a few months back. I posted about an old Bamboo rod my grandpa gave me. My hopes where to get an old reel for it, and make it a usable rig again. The end goal would be to take my grandpa out fishing and use the old bamboo rod, which he thought would never see the light of day again.

 

The rod was given to me by my Grandpa on my Mom's side. Here's a link to the thread.

http://ontariofishingcommunity.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=60203&hl=bamboo&st=0

 

I went to my Grandpa's (on my Dad's side) and rummaged through the boat house today. I found two old reels that I think would be suitable for this old Bamboo Rod.

 

I want OFC to pick what reel I re-build and mount on this old rod.

 

Here are the options:

 

1. A Mitchell Garcia 300.

2. A "Playmaker"....

3. You got something that's been collecting dust that you wanna give away?

 

The Mitchell:

It seems to be a better reel. But it's seen better days. The bail doesn't flip over all the way. It only flips halfway over, then you have to do the rest manually. I think it needs a new spring. And it definitely needs a new paint job, and a little TLC. It's a little big for the rod, which will be used for float fishing crappie / perch. But it feels like a much higher quality reel.

 

The Playmaker:

The reels is in MINT condition. It's nice and light. Very suitable for pan fish. But the quality seems to be lacking (more plastic parts, loose tolerances). But it has a more "basic" design. Less moving parts, and less things to break.

 

What would you choose? And if you feel so inclined.. Why?

 

What ever wins in this poll, I will fix up, re-string and mount on the bamboo rod. My grandpa is coming up on July, and I'm taking him out fishing with this rig.

 

Thanks for your input

Edited May 23, 2012 by N.A.W

[mercman]

too bad its not a baitcaster. I have an old Shakespeare President as old as that rod is.

[woodenboater]

The 300 just cuz it's a classic and was the first spinner I fell in love with. Felt so smooth compared to others I used at the time. Pics of the matched pair when yer done, thx

[DRIFTER_016]

Here is a Nice Reel that would go nicely on that rod and it's a good price too.

 

A nice vintage under spin would be sweet too!!!!

 

Like This One.

Edited May 23, 2012 by DRIFTER_016

[NAW]

too bad its not a baitcaster. I have an old Shakespeare President as old as that rod is.

I remember sing pics you posted of that reel. She's a beaut.

 

Pics of the matched pair when yer done, thx

Sure!

 

Here is a Nice Reel that would go nicely on that rod and it's a good price too.

 

That is a very nice reel, and would be perfect for this rod. But I got a baby due in August. My wife would kill me if I bought another peace of fishing gear!

[woodenboater]

That is a very nice reel, and would be perfect for this rod. But I got a baby due in August. My wife would kill me if I bought another peace of fishing gear!

 

Consider it an early heirloom gift for your soon to be fishing partner

[GBW]

If it was me Nick; I would go with the Mitchell Garcia 300. You can get any needed parts for it I bet way eaiser than the CTC one...

[kickingfrog]

If the outfit doesn't balance it doesn't matter how good the reel was/is.

 

A 2500 stradic on a 5 foot ultralite would suck.

 

For panfish float fishing the reel isn't as critical anyway.

[FishHeadRic]

3.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

FHR

[NAW]

3.

 

 

 

FHR

 

You're right, that is a great looking reel!

[Jacob]

I would say go with the Playmaker. Being a lighter reel it will balence with a light rod and make it easier to handle.

[jigsnreels]

I want OFC to pick what reel I re-build and mount on this old rod.

 

Here are the options:

 

1. A Mitchell Garcia 300.

2. A "Playmaker"....

 

The Mitchell, hands down. The 300 is legend! Besides the instant street cred you will garner amongst your friends when you flash that bad boy in public, once you fix it up you will be able to use it for a lot more than just your old-school nostalgia setup... :-)

[Spiel]

Personally Nick if it were mine I'd just clean her up and display it in a place of honour, great conversational piece.

[fishnsled]

Personally Nick if it were mine I'd just clean her up and display it in a place of honour, great conversational piece.

 

X2 That is what I have done with mine. That reel of FHR's looks pretty cool though.

[NAW]

That will be the end result. I don't plan on making everything look mint again. I want a rustic rig I can hang on my wall.

 

But first, I gotta see my grandpa catch one more fish on it!

[misfish]

Personally Nick if it were mine I'd just clean her up and display it in a place of honour, great conversational piece.

 

Yep,thats what I would do.

 

That will be the end result. I don't plan on making everything look mint again. I want a rustic rig I can hang on my wall.

 

Good choice Nick.

 

gotta see my grandpa catch one more fish

 

Wish I still had that,,,,,,, I got a lot of great memories,that,s all that counts.

[superdad]

I thought originally it was a bamboo fly rod, if it's a spinning rod, then the Mitchell is the way to go, I had my first one in 1958.

 

Do you have any idea as to the age of the rod?

 

Cheers

 

David aka Superdad

[NAW]

I thought originally it was a bamboo fly rod, if it's a spinning rod, then the Mitchell is the way to go, I had my first one in 1958.

 

Do you have any idea as to the age of the rod?

 

Cheers

 

David aka Superdad

 

I'm not to sure the age of the rod. It's in alright condition. A little on the rustic side. But it's all good.

 

My mom remembers using it when she was a little girl. So that would have been 50 years ago.

 

There are some images of the rod in the link to the original thread. Some of the experts here pegged it at 50's - 60's era.

 

The Bamboo rod get be dis-assembled and turned around. Either to be used with a fly reel, or a spinning reel.

Edited May 24, 2012 by N.A.W

[mercman]

Personally Nick if it were mine I'd just clean her up and display it in a place of honour, great conversational piece.

 

 

Great advice Chris.I took it regarding Dads old Eagle Claw.Would hate to be the one that broke it after all those years.

[NAW]

The plan is to set it up for float fishing crappie or perch.

 

I'm thinking about putting on 2lb mono. Hopefully the line will snap before the rod.

 

The tensions still works great on both the reels, and it will be backed right off.

[cisco]

With the small eyelets the rod looks like it's a baitcaster or with the handle switched around it becomes a fly rod. I'd consider getting an old baitcaster and load it with that black or camo old nylon line in 6lbs. Mono as leader below the float. If a spinning rod the first eye up from the reel seat would be wayyy bigger, no?