We all know there is no such thing as safe ice, ESPECIALLY on that lake when there are open sections.
Municipal /provincial authorities will seldom give a complete thumbs up for activities where public judgement vs risk to public is to high. Liability is just to great.
Should you pay if a rescue is warranted ? I don't think so, you pay taxes and part of those taxes involve emergency services no matter how stupid you are.
BUT if your pulled from that lake a second time, your on the hook for something, and thats what the courts are for. Those rescuers did a great job in such adverse conditions, though you may not notice there was a few extremely dicey moments where the rescuers could of turned into victims as well .
Though paid to preform technical rescues such as what unfolded that day the bottom line is a few fish aren't worth a few funerals as the fee you could end up paying is your life or someone else's .
Unbelievably a few of the people rescued thought the emergency services life jackets (400$ a pop) were theirs to keep and slithered of with them.
Hopefully we get a good freeze this year,
Stay safe
R