If it was my money... (which I know it is not..) and if I was looking at resale value.. the 2010 Etec is worth alot more then a already 6 year old motor..
If down the line you decide to sell.. you might not get what you want if the motor is 12, 14 or 16 years old... vs.. 6,8 or 10 years with the ETec...
also there is a difference in technology given the date of the motor you are thinking of buying..
I am not sure if in the long run the 1500 you save now.. will save you 1500 when you decide to sell...
I am not trying to sway you in either direction.. as they are both great engines..
I am just thinking of resale.. a 6 year old model vs. a NEW model.. New or not... people want the latest technology they can afford.
I would also be a bit concerned about the rings, impeller etc in a 6 year old motor that has just been sitting there... perhaps all dried out?
Good luck either way.. I am sure you will have a fine motor when you are done.
be sure to post pics!!
G