Funny, I somehow missed the last few replies to this. Thanks, all. After contacting a few people via PM's and phone calls...we decided on Happy Day lodge. The cabins were booked for the week we wanted, no surprise with the amount of repeat business they get. We did however book a campsite for six nights, which will give us five full days up there to enjoy the fishing, as well as the other family activities they provide.
Juli, the boys, and I are really looking forward to it, and, since we camp every other year...the lack of cabin availability wasn't too much of a concern...maybe cabins next year.