Whitefish on Lake Simcoe is a put and take fishery. Keep your two a day, they will put in another couple of hundred thousand again next year. A hut rental is 30-60 bucks a person . That is 15 to 30 bucks a fish!
You should call, but will they come, I don't think so. You could have watched what cottage he rowed back to and got his address. The cops could then pay him a little visit for a chat when they had time.
Do not say on this site that you are willfully breaking the law with your 12 fish, because your friend catches so many more , you are a POACHER- and nothing else!!....