I stayed at the Waltonian this season.
It was good, but I wouldn't say it was great.
The space heater in the cottage was broken. We asked them to bring another one, they said they would, but never did.
Also, the TV in the cottage was broken. Not that TV was a big deal, but if it's going to be there, then it should at least work.
In terms of fishing, it was pretty terrible. I don't blame the lodge for that...it was just one of those weekends.
For positives: the huts were big and clean, the kid drilling the holes was really good to us, and the restaurant was pretty lively on Saturday night with a live guitarist.
Overall it was a good experience, just not great.