I had the same result 20 years ago in the meat industry. I was headhunted by a competitor.. Two weeks into this and I have to make a decision.
The new job was 30% more pay, and extra week holiday, benefits started day one and an extra $250.00/ month in my car allowance.
I could not sleep the night before I had to talk to my current employer. They had treated me very well and I like working there.
When I talked to my boss the next day, the first question she asked was if I had signed any papers yet. I had not. She said she neede to make a phone call and would be right back.
Three minutes later, her boss was on the phone with me and matched the other companies offer. I accepted it and stayed there two more years.