Hey Tom,
Sorry if my comment rubbed you the wrong way, it was never my intent to insult anyone's home waters.
From what I've seen first hand, there is a great difference between a stocked non self sustaining stateside fish and a wild reproducing GBay or Lake O fish. I guess I shouldn't have grouped all stateside fish in one group, because I'm sure you know as well as I do there is a big difference between a fish from say the Catt compared to a few well know rivers down in PA... It's not just my first hand experience, I'll let the genetics of the fish speak for themselves. Do I feel bad taking roe from a stocked fish that will never successfully reproduce? Nope. Would I feel bad if I was taking roe from a fish that had a very good chance of successfully reproducing on either the US or Canadian side? You bet. I hope my original reply didn't provoke thoughts of a person running down the banks slitting fish open and stealing roe On a few occasions I used my state limit and bagged a couple of hens, also a couple of shakers for my oldmans plate.