Welcome aboard Mustfish!
Life as you know it changed when you joined. This place can be addicting.
Seems we are neighbors so to speak and sounds like we have fished some of the same waters, although most of my fishing time is spent on Lake Erie and I also try to make it to Canada at least a couple weeks a year. I've also done a few flyins and will be doing another May 16.
Pike lures... the large Johnson silver spoons (silver or gold), 5 of diamonds, daredevil spoons and you may want to go to Gander Mountain in Huber and pick up some Grim Reaper spinners bait they have in stock, I've always done well with them. Another thing you may want to try is some swim baits. Going to tell ya my biggest pike to date came on a jig/twister combo and I've caught of lot of pike on the same set up.
Any other help you might need please feel free to pm me.
Cheers