Hmmmmm? Were you expecting someone on the board to make the decision whether to fish Simcoe or Georgian Bay for you? Which one is the closest to you? Can you afford the gas to go to the one that's furthest away?
From what I've seen on the board here, they're both excellent fisheries... probably "twit for tat". Here's an idea! How about fishing them both?!! Fish one now and the other the next time, then let us know which one YOU liked best!
You may also want to use the search function on the board to review/study old threads for each body of water and make your own decision!
Like others have already stated, there's a tremendous amount of help on this board... for reasonable questions!
If you'd like to receive the "picture posting accolades", I'd be glad to help you learn how to post pics.
You've got to admit, reports like this are rather mundane...