And here's my honest answer...
Im wondering what kinda fishing you expect when you hire a guide...
When I hire a guide, I don't expect the fishing to change. Alone or with a guide the fishing will be the same. The experience will be different.
How many fish does it take to keep you happy...
I really don't think that folks' degree of happiness is measured in numbers of fish.
I'm asking this because I'm gunna be getting into guiding and I wanna know how close I am to being good enough...
The numbers of fish the YOU have caught have no bearing on how good a guide you are. Prospective clients probably don't care how many fish YOU caught.
So basically... My walleye average size is about 3 pounds
Prospective out of town clients don't know what the average walleye weighs in Lake St Francis so it's irrelevant.
And musky average is 38-40 inches
I believe the smallest legal fish in your zone is 48"
And carp average is 17-20 pounds
I don't know about carp but you probably won't need a Ranger to catch them.
So if you were to hire me for one of these fish...
How many would satisfy you?
Again, it really has nothing to do with numbers of fish.
And how many to get you to come back?
If you were a real loudmouthed butthole but you managed to get a client a limit of really nice walleye...do you think he'd book with you again? No, I don't think so
Mike, I'm being honest here.
You may very well be an excellent guide but you'll never succeed by simply saying what you've caught. Take some folks fishing....put THEM onto fish and catching a fish then passing the rod off to a client might be a little dicey to a CO.
Take a run at it Mike and good luck to you.