Jump to content

Flasher VS Fishfinder


basketclam

Recommended Posts

Why?

 

It's better for me... i like it more... i've taken my lcd sonar/flasher and i wasn't too impressed...

 

3 colors as opposed to way more.... interference/screen clutter...

 

I can screw up the screen on an lcd sonar/flasher with my marcum... by fishing to close...

 

i don't have that issue with my marcum...

 

it's personal preference again...

 

like i said, if i wanted year round use, i'd by an lcd sonar

for ice fishing, i'll stick with my flasher...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Great info, thanks. I just purchased a Humminbird Ice 45, and I'm thinking of returning it. I like the idea of seeing what's passed by your bait when you weren't looking.

 

Anyone using a fish finder with GPS and maping chips? Any problems?

Edited by redsfishin
Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's better for me... i like it more... i've taken my lcd sonar/flasher and i wasn't too impressed...

 

3 colors as opposed to way more.... interference/screen clutter...

 

I can screw up the screen on an lcd sonar/flasher with my marcum... by fishing to close...

 

i don't have that issue with my marcum...

 

it's personal preference again...

 

like i said, if i wanted year round use, i'd by an lcd sonar

for ice fishing, i'll stick with my flasher...

 

Oh....lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's better for me... i like it more... i've taken my lcd sonar/flasher and i wasn't too impressed...

 

3 colors as opposed to way more.... interference/screen clutter...

 

I can screw up the screen on an lcd sonar/flasher with my marcum... by fishing to close...

 

i don't have that issue with my marcum...

 

it's personal preference again...

 

like i said, if i wanted year round use, i'd by an lcd sonar

for ice fishing, i'll stick with my flasher...

 

It seems that flashers are the way to go for ice fishing but LCD is better for year round fishing. Now if you had a 600W RMS lcd unit then the marcum unit would be all screwed up since the power output is more then 2X. On that note if you want to fish alone then my suggestion is to get a 1000W RMS unit and you won't have to worry about anyone fishing anywhere near you...LOL

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i've fished next to humminbird 787 and have cause very noticable interference on their screen it's 4000W compared to my marcums 2000W

 

 

That's interesting because it means that either yours has greater then 2000W of power or the Humminbird is less then 4000W of power. At 4000W the element would have to be 2" because a 1" element could not handle that kind of power at least not for long. If the humminbird has a 18 degree cone then it cannot be 4000W of power. You may have opened up a can of worms here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just checked the specs on a 787 and they show the cone angle at -10db which is way outside of the industry standard of -3db. In other words they are trying to make their fishfinder appear to have a wider cone angle, very suspect. It is likely the 4000 Watts P2P is on the 83khz and not the 200khz side. So given this information I could see how a marcum would mess with this humminbird unit.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recent Topics

    Popular Topics

    Upcoming Events

    No upcoming events found

×
×
  • Create New...