True, true, I get your point. We may as well all just join P eTA if not harming a fish in any way is the priority.
But there's a big difference between unhooking and releasing a fish quickly and efficiently at boatside and this (to quote Lew):
"Their hooked, then the hooks are pulled back out, then their bounced around in a livewell all day with a bunch of other fish, in a boat going upwards of 60 MPH, then hauled back out and carried to the weigh station, then back to the water and released.......or whatever........"
Again I'm not in any way against the practice, but it simply cannot be argued that it's equally as harmless as normal C&R practices.