Excellent debate. Personally, I think you have to strongly consider your past experience. If all you have fished in is a boat with a console, you will miss it by choosing a tiller and vice versa, if all you have fished with is a tiller, you will miss the lost space in a boat with a console. Either way, be sure to test run each of them before you buy. I drove to Alabama to buy my boat and it was over 5' longer than my previous boat. During the test drive my first thought was "uh oh, this thing weighs a ton". I had done my homework though and after a lengthy test drive and putting the boat through it's paces I warmed up to it pretty quickly. The moral of the story is don't buy something you haven't tested or had any previous experience with.
As far as advice, you can't beat this site as there are a lot of great comments throughout the thread
Good luck.