LOL!
but i'd say it all comes down to the kind of fish. Scugog for Walleye, Crappie, and Perch. Or Simcoe for Whitefish, Lakers, and Perch.
Im not sure if Scugog has rentals, but its a very easy lake to fish. just head for the middle.
And Simcoe has a few, i know theres rentals in Beaverton, they might be able to put you on some fish.