Which Lake Would you Choose?

[Andy]

I have a chance to go fishing Friday to Sunday with a friend who has never fished the Kawarthas.

I've fished Pigeon with mixed results, fishing mainly the north end. Good numbers of bass, a few pickeral, and a musky or two. (I'm likely the worlds worst musky fisherman.) I've never been to Stony.

My friend is mainly a pickeral guy who jigs the shoals on Nipissing alot.

That being said, we have the gear to fish for all species. I have GPS maps for both.

Which lake would you prefer to spend a weekend at?

Thx. Andy

[Bitsmith2k]

I have a chance to go fishing Friday to Sunday with a friend who has never fished the Kawarthas.

I've fished Pigeon with mixed results, fishing mainly the north end. Good numbers of bass, a few pickeral, and a musky or two. (I'm likely the worlds worst musky fisherman.) I've never been to Stony.

My friend is mainly a pickeral guy who jigs the shoals on Nipissing alot.

That being said, we have the gear to fish for all species. I have GPS maps for both.

Which lake would you prefer to spend a weekend at?

Thx. Andy

 

i've got a preference for pigeon.. we'll be out there friday, and i might try to slip in another day this weekend..

[Mr. Follow]

I'd fish Stoney. I've fished Stoney many times During my early years as a musky hunter. Great fishery any time of year.

[Meely]

I have never fished Stoney.....and I aint knock'in it.......but.....

Pigeon would be my lake of choice....lickity-split !!

 

Meely

Edited August 7, 2008 by Meely