Am just getting back on here after a long time but saw this .... Hey Floater....Saw your post and had to reply!! I completely tore my rotator cuff when I was 25-30 yrs old. Back then they wanted to fix it but gave me a 50/50 chance it would help so I didnt do it.... I had pain with it but it wasnt stopping me from living comfortably and could do most anything...I knew not to lift or I would suffer so judged my lifting on a 12 pk or under....In my 50's I was getting more pain and they sent me for pain management.. Cortisone etc... I didnt want to keep putting that stuff in my body for the rest of my life so searched out options... My only option was a shoulder replacement.... Doc said it would allow me more movement and stop pain... (am trying to keep this short) I decided to do it in my early 60's ..... If I could turn back time I would NOT have had it done.... I have more pain ..Less movement now.... Even with physio I can't seem to get back the strength I had....
Floater....no one can tell you whether to do it or not, but weigh everything out.....Right now you can.... Work...Fish.... Hunt...with no issues ...So your living life rather comfortably .... (you didnt mention pain) .... So why fix whats not causing you issues? I am not saying dont do it and not saying do it..... BUT Please really think it through? .... Let us know how it goes for you? Good luck!! 🍀