My group has been staying at Nungesser Lake Lodge; 6 years straight for me, 10+ for the older guys. We always have a great time and are treated well. The lodge is not as new as Angler's Kingdom nor are the boats as nice, but the price is excellent. We also bring in/cook our own food [no American plan] but we actually enjoy this.
http://www.nungesserlake.com/
The lodge has new owners this year, so we'll see what differences/changes there are. New owner is long time resident though so no worries for our group right now. Lodge also has bear hunts for those who want the complete outdoors getaway...