Jump to content

Recommended Posts

https://www.cleveland.com/sports/2019/10/lake-erie-walleye-steelhead-trout-gather-near-shore-and-surprise-muskie-fishing-report-for-oct-25.html?fbclid=IwAR0xQ-HxNergWj1Vm6S6vEYafcxn2pbnN2UIxxBIDvvuvF9MzOva79Y9b1k

I have lived with in 25 miles of the lake my entire life, and this is the first time I have ever heard of  any one in this area intentionally targeting muskies on

lake Erie here, even incidental catches only seemed to get reported on every 25 years or so.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

https://www.cleveland.com/sports/2019/11/lake-erie-walleye-shoreline-and-night-bites-heating-up-fishing-report-for-nov-1.html?fbclid=IwAR2JYMTnN1_XnmLKbIb1sGdeBS5XhJ_tXAJtdVplc7GSWLEQvxtUpHU4eM4

 

12.690 28.50 SHAUN GOOD

11.6.19  Talk about a weight difference in two fish of similar length?

       
6.625 29.50 MARTIN BOSSONE IV

10.18.19

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have heard of a  few Musky caught by guys fishing Largemouth in Long Point Bay the last few years. I have not heard of anyone targeting them specifically. 

Talk about Lake Erie news. I was up all night during that 100 year storm on Halloween. Winds were measured to have been gusting at 150 KPH's. Many homes and cottages had up to 4' of water in them and they are 70 or more feet across Lakeshore road from the lake. My buddies large deck that was built by his Dad in the early 60's ended up on the neighbours lawn 4 door down the road. Another pals old place (RIP Big Show) that his daughter now has has an 80' Willow tree in the living room. With all the torrential rain it might be a write off. Numerous friends and neighbours lost shingles and rain soaked through to the drywall. The county brought out the snow graders back hoes and loaders to clear huge logs, pieces of boathouses, boats, boat lifts and decks as well as the foot or more of sand and mud on Lakeshore road. They are still working today scooping out debris in the drainage ditches. We faired pretty well. a dead Ash tree on the bank snapped about 4' above the roots and was stopped from hitting our place by a small branch on a Maple tree or we would have had a major problem. My boat cover was ripped open and when it isn't blowing here I need to get the Zebra Mussels off the seats and dash. Lost a small section of grass on the bank but no big deal, not a  shingle lost. When I had the roof done 5 years ago I insisted the contractor fasten all the shingles down as it said in that little piece of paper no one reads when they tear open a bundle. I was up all night, I thought we were. I thought we were on our way to Kansas. We got lucky.  

By the way or cottage is listed for sale. To see it just Google 16 Hoover Point Lane Selkirk On. My wife did a beautiful job decorating or as they say staging it. My credit card has more damage on it than that storm. 

Johnny D

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Nice fish Pigeon! Years ago I caught pike in the very early spring here, never personally caught a ski or even hooked one fishing Erie. About 40 years ago a friend caught one around 10 pounds around the Avon Lake power plant and he was a straight up guy so I believed it. They would make the Lake a bit more interesting to fish?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Paul, more reports of people catching muskies by accident in the western basin and island area the past few years. Guys that are targeting them are tight lipped about what they are doing. The few that I have seen look just like the St Clair fish and I suspect that is where they are coming from.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, Whopper said:

Paul, more reports of people catching muskies by accident in the western basin and island area the past few years. Guys that are targeting them are tight lipped about what they are doing. The few that I have seen look just like the St Clair fish and I suspect that is where they are coming from.

Bunch of them in the upper Niagara River at the other end of Erie as well. Heard of a few being caught in Gravelly Bay at Port Colborne as well.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, Whopper said:

Paul, more reports of people catching muskies by accident in the western basin and island area the past few years. Guys that are targeting them are tight lipped about what they are doing. The few that I have seen look just like the St Clair fish and I suspect that is where they are coming from.

Hi Phil! It would make sense that some of those Lake St. Clair fish would wander down this way? Have you seen any new areas of weed growth around the island area? I can picture them finding a mix of habitat in Sandusky Bay or possibly East Harbor but the main lake was pretty devoid of weeds. Still fishing with  Captain Joe?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
2 hours ago, dave524 said:

Bunch of them in the upper Niagara River at the other end of Erie as well. Heard of a few being caught in Gravelly Bay at Port Colborne as well.

Saw some videos of guys fishing the Buffalo harbor area and catching them too, LOL, one charter captain didn't want that stinky fish in his boat.

At times I wonder about DNR's decisions, they could have stocked muskies on this side instead of Coho or Steelhead? Not a species that wasn't native, although at one point in time there may have been trout here, LOL before humans improved things?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks Paul, yes Tich did a great job both using the brad nailer once she got the hang of it, she loves it, as well as decorating. The amazing thing here was after the storm we had a sandy beach again. We haven't had beach for 3 years. It means your side of the lake or east or west of us had higher shoreline like we had on the 31st and 1st. They call it " the bathtub effect." When the south shore of the lake is getting pounded the north shore levels drop and vice versa. 

Very nice Musky Pigeontroller. Like I said only a few reports I have read or heard personally of Musky catches in Long Point Bay or the western basin. Musky guys are tight lipped. It's a lot of work and expense to target those things. Heck those bricks you guys toss at them are 20 bucks or more. I don't blame them for being members of a secret society. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Buffalo Harbor was a real hot spot in the 90s due to a warm water discharge that's no longer a factor, and I'm guessing some real good year classes. Googling Buffalo Harbor Musky will show you some incredible specimens with 50'' lengths and  huge girths. Long Point Bay gets mentioned more and more...Anywhere there's good spawning water will attract Muskies, they usually arrive in fall and winter over, make love come spring time and then head out to the blue water to eat all summer long...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
7 hours ago, AKRISONER said:

PAUL castellano hooked one in the Niagara river during the 39 hours series on YouTube 

Lot's of big muskies recently on the " FishIn  Niagara " facebook page out of the Niagara River.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
6 hours ago, OhioFisherman said:

http://www.rockthelake.com/buzz/2018/01/muskie-caught-ice-fishing/

A rare central basin muskie, that one didn't get a chance to spawn.

The article goes onto explain the angler got not just 1 outside Cleveland which is a rarity but he hooked a second Musky that broke him off. What are the odds? It also said the angler plans on mounting his 40 some odd incher. Didn't say anything about a replimount (new word). Too bad he had to kill it. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...

  • Similar Topics

    • 3 rods per angler on US side of Erie

      Saw this on another forum.   http://wildlife.ohiodnr.gov/wildlife-home/post/ohio-wildlife-council-approves-3rd-fishing-line-for-lake-erie-ohio-river As long as they don't increase the limits it won't impact anything.  I don't know why they don't allow 2 rods per person on Georgian Bay except that it is a way to have limits that are very hard to reach.  If would be nice to have a 2 rod rule on G-Bay.  

      in General Discussion

    • Where to find what baitfish are in a lake?

      The Ontario website (fishonline) doesn’t say what bait fish are in lakes, only the larger fish.   im looking to find out what type of minnow type of fish are in lakes. Like gobys, shiners, shad, etc.   i know I can see what type of panfish are in the fishonline site. I’ve never seen shad in the lakes I fish but wondering if they’re their. 

      in General Discussion

    • Lake Erie, southside, and the Fall Brawl news

      https://www.cleveland.com/sports/2019/10/lake-erie-walleye-perch-fishing-blown-away-by-big-winds-fishing-report-for-oct-18.html?fbclid=IwAR316UpCoYe6aYOIkxYpa0seNYuJgFNYAXwSH1X1t6jTQrj9R47RKnMVteI That storm affected the opening day of the Fall Brawl, from what I could see only two fish were entered on day 1, that changed on Saturday with quite a few entries, although I don't see any of them counting in the end results. http://www.lakeeriefishingderby.com/2019-standings.html

      in General Discussion

    • Seymour Lake (Trent River)- Solider Weed?

      Hey All,  I have a cottage on Seymour Lake, and it seemed like the fishing was way down this year- Bass, Pike, Walleye (don't really target),  even Sunfish. Also, haven't caught a muskie in year, I'm assuming it has to do with the Pike taking over, still surprised tho.  I know they've sprayed really aggressively for solider weed the past few falls, and thought that might have something to do with? Anyways curious to hear your thoughts, and what you've experienced on the water. Tha

      in General Discussion

    • Gobies in Guelph Lake

      I heard a rumor that there are Gobies in Guelph Lake.  Can anyone confirm that?  It would be bad if there are!

      in General Discussion

×
×
  • Create New...