I am planning to go go out and fish off the Lakehurst causeway over Pigeon and Buckhorn Lake on Saturday evening and need some advice on lures and colours to use. I was there last weekend and had success using Northland Tackle Slurpies (perch colour) for panfish, actually caught a 12-13" largemouth with it. I lost a white and silver Jawbreaker spoon though which I will probably replace since I noticed a couple other people using a similar lure with some success.
I have a frog lure for the surface and a few black white jigs with White Yum Walleye grubs that got some attention last time as well as a nice jointed minnow lure that looks to have some potential but it also runs pretty shallow. Can anyone give me advice on what other lures I should look at adding to my collection for Buckhorn, Lower Buckhorn, Pigeon and Chemong lakes? I noted in some previous threads that combinations with black seem to be popular choices for those lakes.
One other question actually. How long do those scented baits like Yum and Gulp and the Slurpies last in the water before I should replace them with a fresh one?
Thanks for any advice everyone.